Only 38% of women in the UK believe the Government’s Covid 19 response has focused on issues that matter most to them
Date Posted: Wednesday 31st March 2021
Less than one third of young women and disabled women believe the government is acting in their best interests.
Just 38% of women in the UK believe the Government is focusing on issues that matter most to them in its response to the pandemic – this compares to 50% of men, according to new polling published today by six leading gender equality organisations. This new research demonstrates that the government must do more to support women and girls as focus turns towards recovery from the coronavirus pandemic. In addition, it is essential that women have a voice at Government’s decision-making table.
The polling, carried out by Survation for six women’s organisations: Close the Gap, Engender, Fawcett Society, Northern Ireland Women’s Budget Group, Women’s Budget Group, and Women’s Equality Network Wales also shows that less than a third (29%) of women believe women’s specific needs have been considered or addressed in the Governments response to Covid- 19 compared to 34% of men.
Research over the past year has shown that women have been hit hardest by the social and economic impacts of Covid-19 with Black, Asian and Ethnic Minority women, young women, women in low-income households, disabled women, single mothers and those with caring responsibilities particularly badly affected.
Today’s polling shows that amongst groups most affected by the pandemic only 31% of young women (age 18-30) believe the UK Government is acting in their best interests compared to 52% of older women (age 46+), while only 32% of disabled women agree that the UK Government is acting in their best interests compared to 45% of non-disabled women.
The findings also further highlight that those at the sharp end of the pandemic, the majority of whom are women, have experienced a decline in their overall wellbeing and mental health.
- Almost half of women (47%) report that their mental health has worsened since the pandemic began compared to one third (34%) of men. Rates were highest among young women (55%), disabled women (54%) and women in part-time employment (59%).
- One third (32%) of young women and one quarter (25%) of disabled women and mothers started to seek support or sought more support for their mental health.
- 47% of women reported that their quality of sleep had worsened since before the pandemic compared to 38% of men.
Given this disproportionate impact of the coronavirus pandemic on women – and the under representation of women in government – it is not surprising that they feel their needs have not been met by the UK Government’s response. Action is urgently needed from the Government to ensure that women’s voices and talents, in all our diversity, are not overlooked and the pandemic does not turn back decades of progress on women’s rights and equality.
Dr Mary Ann Stephenson, Director of Women’s Budget Group, said:
“There has been growing evidence that the pandemic and the Government’s response risks putting equality for women into reverse. So, it isn’t surprising that so few women believe their needs have been met by Government. Over the last year Women’s Budget Group amongst other equality groups have repeatedly warned the government about the need to carry out impact assessments of their response to the pandemic. This is the fallout of not heeding these warnings. We urgently need a targeted strategy for vulnerable groups that tackles the unequal economic impact of the Covid-19 pandemic.”
Felicia Willow, Fawcett Society Chief Executive, said:
“Over the past year, our research has revealed time and again that the pandemic is having a disproportionate impact on women. Government policy to date has failed to understand and protect the needs of women and, in some cases, has simply worsened inequality. This research demonstrates that this hasn’t gone by unnoticed by women. If the Government wants to show that it supports women, there needs to be more women at the decision-making table. We need the Government to commit meaningfully to improving equality for all kinds so that women – and particularly those who face multiple levels of discrimination- don’t continue to lose out.”
Emma Ritch, Executive Director of Engender, said:
“As we approach the anniversary of the first COVID-19 lockdown, it is clear that women in Scotland and across the UK have seen life get much harder during the pandemic. Twice as many women than men in Scotland say their mental health has worsened since before March 2020. Young women, disabled women, and Black and minoritised women were more likely to work in sectors that have been shuttered and are now reporting that they are struggling to make ends meet. Decision-makers need to take steps now to protect women’s jobs, incomes, and health as we move into recovery.”
Anna Ritchie Allan, Executive Director of Close the Gap, said:
“This data underscores that the Covid response is failing to meet women’s needs. Young women, disabled women, low-paid women, single parents and women in part-time work are even less likely to believe that the UK Government is acting in their best interests. Covid-19 has negatively affected women’s employment, financial security and mental health. We need action now to ensure that economic recovery doesn’t worsen women’s inequality.”
Catherine Fookes, Director of Women’s Equality Network Wales, said:
“One year on from the first Covid-19 lockdown, and there continues to be an urgent need to address the clear and growing inequalities exposed by the pandemic. Throughout the year, our research has shown that women, and in particular disabled women, BAME women, and lower income women have all been impacted disproportionately by the pandemic and the policies enacted in response. It is clear from the latest polling that a majority of women in the UK do not believe the issues that matter most to them are being addressed. We need to see a diversity of women in decision-making positions so that our political institutions reflect the society we live in and a wider breadth of experiences to address the needs of all women with targeted policies and funding.”
Alexandra Brennan, Coordinator at Northern Ireland Women’s Budget Group (NIWBG), said:
“From this data it is clear that support for crucial policy initiatives like the implementation of the Real Living Wage, no threshold for Statutory Sick Pay, ending the two-child limit and the lifting of ‘no recourse to public funds’ exists across the political spectrum. The UK Government’s current approach is not representative of these ideals, which perpetuates the disproportionate impact of the pandemic on women and others. This briefing shows that inclusive reform is both desperately needed and widely supported.”
Rebecca Graham, from Standard Life Foundation, said:
“We have seen so much evidence over the last year showing that while support mechanisms such as the Job Retention Scheme and the uplift to Universal Credit are welcome, they are simply not enough to prevent increasing inequality. The needs of groups including women on low incomes, Disabled women and Black, Asian and minority ethnicity women must be given specific consideration and the recommendations of groups representing them heard in making decisions on ongoing support.”
Together, we’re calling for:
- More representation: The government needs to include more women at the decision-making table and create strong structures to engage with the women’s and wider equalities sector.
- Stronger safety net: This pandemic highlighted the importance of social security to alleviate and prevent poverty. The holes in this safety net were also put to stark relief. Child benefit, a crucial source of women’s and children’s income, should be increased and support for low-income families and unemployed people improved to provide better living standards. Legacy benefits (including Job Seeker’s Allowance and Employment and Support Allowance) should be increased in line with the £20 uplift to Universal Credit.
- Sectoral support: Post-COVID recovery needs to include support for hardest hit sectors like retail, hospitality, leisure and tourism, sectors that are important employers of women and young people.
- Investment in care: Urgent funding is required for the early years sector to avoid widespread closures which would have a huge impact on women’s employment. Sustainable funding and longer-term major reform are sorely needed for both the early years and the social care sectors.
Further findings of the research:
Women do not feel the UK Government’s response has met their needs:
- 43% of women said the UK Government is acting in their best interests in its response to the pandemic compared to 50% of men
- 24% of women said their physical health needs had been met by the UK Government’s response compared to 32% of men
- 21% of women said their financial needs had been met by the UK Government’s response compared to 27% of men.
Women’s mental health and wellbeing is suffering:
- 53% of women said they were finding it harder to both stay positive day-to-day and about the future compared to 43% of men
- 34% of women reported that their diet and nutrition had worsened since before the pandemic compared to 26% of men
- 45% of women reported a decline in their levels of exercise compared to 36% of men.
The pandemic is exacerbating already existing inequality:
- 35% of women on low incomes (household income of £0-19,999 annually) believe they will come out of the pandemic in more debt than before compared to 19% of women on high incomes (household income of over £40,000 annually) and 34% of disabled women believe they will have more debt compared to 24% of non-disabled women
- 35% of mothers worry that they will struggle to make ends meet in the next three months compared to 21% of women without children
- 30% of Black, Asian and Ethnic Minority women are worried about how they will pay their rent or mortgage compared to 17% of white women.
Notes on methodology:
Our research is drawn from data collected by Survation with fieldwork conducted 18th February 2021. The survey was conducted via an online panel. Invitations to complete surveys were sent out to members of online panels. The population sampled were people in the UK aged 18 and over. The sample size was 1,004.
Press office contacts:
Women’s Budget Group
Thaira Mhearban: firstname.lastname@example.org / 07838 222067/ Communications Officer
Dr Mary-Ann Stephenson: email@example.com / 07957 338582/ Director
For further information, please contact:
Fresh Communication/ 0117 369 0025
Nathalie Golden: firstname.lastname@example.org / 07769 66 66 27
Lisa Sutherland: email@example.com / 07801 97 99 87
Alys Mumford: firstname.lastname@example.org/ 07889805785/ Communications & Engagement Manager
Close the Gap
Anna Ritchie Allan: email@example.com/ 07711 926 833/ Executive Director
Women’s Equality Network Wales
Catherine Fookes: 07511 939235/ firstname.lastname@example.org
Megan Evans: 07716 433192/ email@example.com
Northern Ireland Women’s Budget Group
Alexandra Brennan: Coordinator/ firstname.lastname@example.org
Standard Life Foundation
Standard Life Foundation has supported this as part of its mission to contribute towards strategic change which improves financial well-being in the UK. The Foundation funds research, policy work and campaigning activities to tackle financial problems and improve living standards for people on low-to-middle incomes in the UK. It is an independent charitable foundation registered in Scotland (SC040877).
Joseph Rowntree Reform Trust
This study was funded by the Joseph Rowntree Reform Trust (JRRT). Responding to the growing crisis of democracy and erosion of trust in the political class and institutions, JRRT’s priority area of work for both grant-making and external activities is democratic and political reform.
Close the Gap has almost two decades’ experience of working with policymakers, employers, and unions on women and work. They are experts on the barriers which affect women’s participation in Scotland’s labour market.
Engender is a policy organisation and through their research and analysis they aim to make women’s inequality visible and persuade those with power to make positive changes to services, policy, regulation, practices, and laws that negatively affect women.
The Fawcett Society is the UK’s leading membership charity campaigning for gender equality and women’s rights at work, at home and in public life. Our vision is a society in which women and girls in all their diversity are equal and truly free to fulfil their potential creating a stronger, happier, better future for us all.
The Northern Ireland Women’s Budget Group is an independent network that analyses economic policy in Northern Ireland to understand its impact on women and men and promotes alternatives for a gender equal economy.
The Women’s Budget Group (WBG) is an independent network of leading academic researchers, policy experts and campaigners that analyses economic policy for its impact on women and men and promotes alternatives for a gender equal economy. Our work on coronavirus can be accessed at: https://wbg.org.uk/topics/covid-19/
The Women’s Equality Network Wales work with a vibrant coalition of organisational and individual members to transform society – They believe that no one organisation alone can deliver equality. Their work sits under three pillars. They work to Connect, Campaign and Champion women so their vision of a world where men and women have equal authority and opportunity is realised.